Lackey is going to be overrated and Montgomery is going to be underrated by metrics that try to normalize batted ball profiles. Montgomery is very hard to square up and gets a lot of groundballs, while Lackey is a strike thrower who has lost a tick and is now in an environment where more strikes than ever end up at or over the fence. Montgomery isn't perfect, and he hasn't seized the starting chance like I hoped he might, but he is still easily the 5th best SP we have. Lackey has to accept that the ball is juiced and stop throwing pitches away. Focus on every single pitch. When in the past he would get pop flies, now they're leaving the yard. It feels like a lot of those HR have come on first pitch fastballs down the pipe. Blatant arrogance. But with Monty, like most 5th starters, his numbers the 2nd time through the order are really bad across the board. I'm more confident that Lackey can get closer to his previous levels ('15-16 especially) than Monty can navigate through lineups multiple times more consistently. He just doesn't have the control and command of his fastball for me. And I've already stated how much I want him in the long role. With this staff (although I admit maybe things are turning especially with the add of Q, Jake's last 11 starts, and Kyle's imminent return) usually unable to go deep, he protects the pen a lot. When he gets shelled, our pen gets burnt. I think I prefer going outside the organization for that spot but if they choose not to, I think Lackey should get it.