Yeah I'm sure there's an explanation for this but looking at it a little closer I don't think it's quite apples to apples, and I think the error comes from the FG not recognizing any sort of defensive contributions from pitchers for 2026, whereas in 2016 Lester (lol), Arrieta, Lackey, Hammer all contributed pretty sizable defensive value. Removing the pitchers from the list, if my quick math is right, puts that team at 50.4, so we're probably right on line with that, if not a little ahead.
All in all, probably safe to say the offensive group is on par with the 2016 group. Pitching has been a very different story.