He was better against righties the past two years, but he was still really good against lefties, too. I’ve got no problem with the lineup. Murphy’s probably going to be leadoff a lot and since this is his first game, Joe just threw him there. Everyone complained about Rizzo batting there since nobody was on base for him so that eliminates him and Javy. You’re not putting Heyward there. Almora, Contreras and Happ have all been varying degrees of crap and Bote has done nothing since the slam. So you’re left with Zobrist. Swapping them would be fine or even moving Zo up and moving the other three down a spot but then you’re just shuffling the same four. I know it doesn't ultimately matter over a one game sample. It's just concerning about the thought process that leads to these decisions. Maddon comes out today and says the reason Murphy is leading off is so he can get the most ABs possible before replacing him for defensive purposes, which raises two major issues. One, we have a DH spot available, and two, that just means that he's going to get pulled before he might be in an advantageous spot of facing a righty reliever. Him getting three PAs against Liriano and then getting pulled is the worst way to use him.