Now its down to simply what if's? Seriously, that Johnson incident is really getting overblown. He made a mistake as a manager. It's done. He took correct action after the matter. Johnson will be one of Florida's top arms in 2007. He made a mistake that, as CubinNY pointed out, he's seen made before (and caused great damage to Lieber). He made a really big mistake, one that shows poor judgement in regards to pitcher's health. We don't know that Girardi corrected his action - your quote indicates that Johnson won't pitch if it's a little sprain. That doesn't tell us that Joe thought he made a mistake or anything, just that he won't pitch his player if he's hurt (which isn't a shocker, since that's the doctor's decision). I don't see how I (or anyone else) is overblowing a decision that Girardi made that not only goes against common logic and risks severe injury to a young player but is a mistake he saw his manager make 5 years ago. Garenhire did an admirable job with Liriano. Francisco was in the 140s in PAP (it would be higher if he hadn't missed time, but even then, it'd probably have been between 50 and 100), he averaged 89.4 pitches/start. The Twins treated him very gingerly, whether it was starting the season in the pen or the team being careful with him when he was coming back. I think Gardenhire is an awful manager in terms of in-game decisions and lineup construction, but the way he brought along Liriano (and Sanatana a few years ago) were great.