The way I see it, assuming we aren't able or even trying to dump Dempster/Marquis/Eyre, you have two choices: Fukudome and not lose valuable young players at minimum salary (Gallagher, Marshall, Murton, etc.) or Roberts and Figgins and losing at least a few you players at minimum salary Lineup One: Soriano DeRosa Lee Ramirez Fukudome Soto Theriot Pie All your young players Lineup Two: Roberts Figgins Lee Ramirez Soriano Murton/DeRosa Soto Theriot That just because I can't see all three of Fukudome, Roberts, and Figgins' salaries fitting unless we move Marquis/Dempster/Eyre, but considering that we are probably losing our cheap replacement pitchers like Marshall or Gallagher in those moves, you don't have many options for 4/5 starter and bullpen. If we could get one of Figgins/Roberts I'm not sure who would be better. Roberts is a better bet to hit well, whereas Figgins could fill a position where we have a hole, as well as having "versatility"