Across AAA and MLB this year, Little has a 4.65 ERA and 5.53 FIP, he's struck out 1 more batter than he's walked. He has objectively not pitched well, and my posts are explaining the whys that are driving that. These are small samples, just like the samples are small of him pitching a bit better in AAA/MLB last year, and that is part of the point being made. The answer of why Little can look good is obvious, he throws upper 90s from a brutal angle for LHH and gets like 30 feet of extension due to being part redwood. The answer of why Little has been less good is what I'm saying, that he's going to look great sometimes and horrible some others. It is not that Little's 2024 line is what you expect of him going forward, or that he's hopeless to ever sort out these problems. But these are the problems that have existed with his profile the whole time, it's why he got quickly moved to the pen, it's why his run prevention was merely 'good' in AA despite striking out 16 per 9, and it's why he's struggling with consistency at the high minors/MLB level now.
You've created this fiction in your head that this skepticism is writing him off as useless and representative of demanding finished products of young players the moment they hit MLB. Not only is that obvious nonsense, it leads to a much less interesting conversation than actually talking about the player and performance involved.