Perry is a good hitting coach who preaches the right things. However, we have pretty much wholesale underachievement from the offense, a staggering number of people performing below projections. If there was a situation where the hitting coach could be blamed, this might be it. Joshua's promotion is very well deserved. And if any coaching change could make a tangible impact on how the hitters are going to perform, I think this would be it. However, I think there's a lost opportunity to have Joshua be involved with the more formative development for players in our system, and that's something that's crucial in a system with so little history of coaching up hitters well. All in all, I can't fault the team for doing this, but if the hitting continues to underachieve then I think it will have been a mistake. Because odds are now Joshua won't go back to being a minor league hitting coach, and his talents will be wasted on those who either don't need his instruction, won't listen to it from being in the majors too long, or are beyond his help from being in baseball too long.