Transmogrified Tiger
-
Posts
38,765 -
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Days Won
70
Content Type
Profiles
Joomla Posts 1
Chicago Cubs Videos
Chicago Cubs Free Agent & Trade Rumors, Notes, & Tidbits
2026 Chicago Cubs Top Prospects Ranking
News
2023 Chicago Cubs Draft Picks
Guides & Resources
2024 Chicago Cubs Draft Picks
The Chicago Cubs Players Project
2025 Chicago Cubs Draft Pick Tracker
2026 Chicago Cubs Draft Tracker: Picks & Bonuses
Blogs
Events
Forums
Store
Gallery
Everything posted by Transmogrified Tiger
-
This is an honest question, but why is fWAR a better indication of WAR than bWAR? bWAR has Heyward and Harper averaging the same amount of wins the last 6 years. fWAR rates Harper better. 1. It doesn't matter! Using Jason Heyward's 2013-2015(which is like 75% of that 6 year span WAR) as anything representative of what Heyward is going to do in 2019 and beyond is crazy. That ship has sailed, Heyward is not that player any more, we have 3 years and 2000ish plate appearances as proof. 2. bWAR is simply less accurate. For pitchers it can be a worthy counterpart to fWAR because it is more descriptive while fWAR is more predictive(e.g. ERA v. FIP), but for hitters there's no reason to use anything you see on BR outside of using the DRS defensive values for comparison/validation to what UZR is saying.
-
-
Schwarber for non-major leaguers(pitchers at that) is an unserious idea, regardless of their pedigree or readiness. -
I'm really glad that Dave Cameron works for the Padres now so I don't have to roll my eyes at every 'opt-outs only have downside for a team' mention that ignores that's how you get the player on your team in the first place.
-
Correct, the same idea applies to someone who is Arb 2 or 3 coming off a terrible season. That proposed contract structure seems pretty sure to be vetoed, or the odds of Harper being able to leverage it into some team(Cubs or otherwise) just giving him 10/400 or 10/425 without the shenanigans are pretty high. Not that you can't get creative, but there needs to be something in it for the player and there isn't really in that case.
-
That was way funnier than it had any right to be.
-
Oh could the brewers not get 7 innings of 0-1 run ball from their bullpen for 10 straight games
-
You have an incredible gift for incorrect sanctimony, it is your superpower
-
A backup catcher is playing about as much as Lackey did, I doubt that would be a huge issue. My concern is that at this stage in his career, I’m not sure what McCann is actually good at. Framing has been below average for a couple years, and his bat fell off a cliff this year.
-
We should all be able to agree that Aguilar is a bear wearing a human suit trying and failing to play first base, and also that Machado unnecessarily took a dangerous and dirty swipe at him
-
Please don’t take another job this year Brandon Hyde
-
General Baseball Chit-Chat Thread
Transmogrified Tiger replied to David's topic in General Baseball Talk
THATS GR GREAT TO HEAR -
Did it really have to be these 2 teams
-
the lack of juiced balls could explain less power in the league, but is there another team that had a 25% loss in hrs? Its an honest question. 11 teams lost at least 19%, 5 lost at least 24%, but those other 4 are more explainable(Marlins, Mets, Tigers, Rays)
-
The average team hit 20 fewer HR than last year, and Bryant alone is another 15. they hit 56 fewer hr's. Everyone not named BAEZ loss power. And Baez alone accounted for 11 additional hr's that Bryant didn't hit between the years. Overall, the offense loss power and rather dramatically. Overall OPS took a 31 point loss. 62 fewer runs over the 162 game schedule. That's Chiliball with a sprinkling of Maddon enabling. Chili gets his blame*. *I don't feel death threats are appropriate League-wide OPS dropped 25 points and teams scored 30 runs fewer on average. The Cubs lost 27 points in slugging, the league lost 18. The gaps between that and the Cubs are even narrower considering how important Bryant is to the offense(2018 Baez was as close to 2017 Almora in offensive output as he was 2017 Bryant). This is not a #freeChili campaign, and I think you can lay a small part of the offense's inconsistency and power down turn at his feet. But the idea that counting numbers went down and that's on Chili is ignoring the two most important reasons, Bryant's injury and league-wide offense regressing.
-
I think Bryant's injury was the biggest issue. If he's healthy they score a couple more runs and probably win at least one more game. Nobody complains. Bryant's injury was a big factor clearly, but dropping 60+ hr's from year to year isn't due to one guy. The average team hit 20 fewer HR than last year, and Bryant alone is another 15.
-
How much do you think hitting coaches actually matter? Mallee got fired because there was a lot of stagnation/regression, Schwarber most notably but also Russell, no progression from Baez, etc. I won't argue that there's clearly some philosophical differences and that if the players don't have faith you need to move on, but a single season where the team went from 3rd in the NL in wRC+ to...3rd in the NL in wRC+ is well within the range of any number of factors independent of the hitting coach too.
-
really? i think he's worse and thought he was decent at csn I think he's always looking for the narrative that is what someone(be it the team or some portion of the fanbase) doesn't want to hear, I'm sure there's some logic for it from a journalistic sense. I think Sharma has rubbed off on him in a positive way so that those narrative takes are at least more informed or subdued if they aren't. That entitled second place team nonsense though, woof. As bad as anything he did at CSN.
-
Mooney has gotten better since joining the Athletic but that is a terrible take. However, I can get on board with the sentiment that Chili should not be back but that he'll take way more blame from both fans and players than he deserves.
-
According to Kaplan, KB turned down 200 Mill Extension
Transmogrified Tiger replied to davell's topic in Chicago Cubs Talk
Boras insists on his client reaching free agency, news at 11 -
I generally like players with Kipnis' skillset, but he's now at about 1000 PA with a wOBA around .305, he's not adding value defensively, and at 32 and with one year left on his deal there's little benefit to adding him with Zobrist around and LH corner OFs not in short supply(Heyward, Happ, Schwarber, hopefully Harper). Not hard to make the argument that La Stella is a player better suited to this roster, and that's before getting to the salary difference.
-
They were basically identical hitters and baserunners, but UZR thinks Baez was a terrible defensive SS and 3B, and mediocre 2B, while thinking Lindor was a +13 SS.
-
Not a difficult argument to make that Hoerner is our top prospect today, never mind 12 months from now.
-
Scam Sites
Transmogrified Tiger replied to Derwood's topic in North Side Baseball Issues & Suggestions
I haven't seen this here, but I have seen the same thing on and off at Fangraphs recently, really annoying because they put so many redirects that sometimes it's really difficult to even use the back button. Seems most logical that it's a rogue ad or two. -
Would I want Starlin Castro on the team given the things he's been accused of personally? No. Would I want to trade for him given that he's been a slightly below average second baseman for multiple years and hits right handed like all of our other IF options? Also no. Would I take him for free considering he makes 11 million dollars this year and 8+ million towards the tax? No again.
