As who promised? Some NSBB folks? Rhodes is a respectable arm that Philly needs. Michaels is a spare bench player. Rhodes, like all relievers, is inconsistant. Michaels is a spare bench player with a .380 career OBP. If the Cubs had a lineup full of "spare bench players," they'd have one of the better offenses in the league. The fact that the Phillies are settling on Arthor Rhodes for Michaels, tells you the value Jason Michaels has around baseball. He couldn't beat out the likes of Glanville, Ledee, and Bryd, for goodness sakes. And that decision making got the Phillies what? the second best offense in the NL in 2005, the third best offense in the NL in 2004, and the fifth best offense in the NL in 2003. Yes, Abreu, Thome, and Burrell are good hitters. That's not the point. Your logic to devalue a player is based on accepting the decision making of an organization that hasn't been very successful, and just fired said decision maker.