Jump to content
North Side Baseball

raw

Community Moderator
  • Posts

    5,716
  • Joined

  • Days Won

    7

 Content Type 

Profiles

Chicago Cubs Videos

Chicago Cubs Trade & Free Agent Rumors

2026 Chicago Cubs Top Prospect Rankings

Chicago Cubs News, Rumors & Analysis

2023 Chicago Cubs Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

Chicago Cubs Fan Guides & Resources

2024 Chicago Cubs Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

2025 Chicago Cubs Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

2026 Chicago Cubs Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

Blogs

Events

Forums

Store

Gallery

Everything posted by raw

  1. The hell you do that for Almora? Reds now within 1.
  2. Being a better pitcher There's really no evidence to back this up. Hendricks incredible 2016? Yeah, Quintana had a higher WAR. This year in total? Quintana. The last 30 days? Quintana. What are you basing it on? You're giving Quintana a boost for 5.1 WAR vs. 5.0 in 2016, but then going to last 30 days to dismiss 3.2 WAR to 2.5 in Hendricks favor this year? Main difference in 2016 was 18 innings more than Quintana pitched. Hendricks peripherals better across the board.
  3. That plan may have been the plan before the season or before the last 2 games. Just reporting what I've read (Brad Biggs column). But the week 8 theory makes some sense using flawed John Fox logic. Didn't start him the first 3 weeks, this is a short week. Not enough prep for Mitch. Next 3 games are strong defenses: Minnesota, Baltimore, Carolina. New Orleans gives him a chance to start on the road without all the home game hype. It also gives him a chance to start and then the Bears have an extra week to evaluate him and fix whatever needs to be tweaked during the bye. Like I said, it's not very sound logic, but it probably makes sense to a person that is willing to start a QB after a 100 yard passing game following a disaster start coming off a bad preseason when you have a potentially elite player behind him......if Fox is in fact willing to start Glennon.
  4. Just for fun let's start an IF of Caratini, Zobrist, Freeman and LaStella the day after we clinch and see how bad it gets And Schwarber is catching Jon Lester.
  5. He's clearly our best starter right now. I dont really mind if Lester gets game 1. Even I kind of expect him to come up big in the big game even though he's been struggling, and he was improved last night. But then game 2 has to go to Hendricks. Lester/Hendricks/Q/Jake/Lester is what I expect. Hendricks/Q/Lester/Jake/Hendricks is what I would probably go with Lester/Jake/Q/Hendricks/Lester is what Dusty would do, and if Joe does it Ill jump on the fire Joe bandwagon What's the argument for Hendricks over Quintana? Being a better pitcher
  6. Nacho guy's shirt is tight as horsefeathers.
  7. There's been multiple people around the Bears hinting that the Bears have targeted the Saints game in New Orleans as the game Trubisky takes over the starting QB job. For those scoring at home, that's Week 8.
  8. Goldman has been really good in the 2 close games. It's no secret why the Bears have had success shutting down the run despite shuffling ILBs in and out.
  9. Starting him Thursday also gives a division rival little time to prepare for a QB change. The Texans started Watson week 2, on a Thursday night. Of course, he did get into the game week 1. It wouldn't be the worst idea in the world to start him this week. If you think he honestly gives the team the best chance to win and today's win may have salvaged the team's chances at competing this year....you kinda have to play him this week. if you play him, don't announce it Agreed.
  10. Yeah in some ways I feel bad but man that kind of thing just cannot happen. Oh well, we won despite it and I'm sure he learned his lesson. Huge letters in the endzone. Run til you step on orange. No excuse for that play.
  11. i mentioned this at some point before, but green bay's defense is so bad. i know everyone wants to give trubisky that long week to prep for minnesota, but that's a much better defense than green bay. there's not gonna be some ideal scenario, but the vaunted packers are as easy a target as any. Starting him Thursday also gives a division rival little time to prepare for a QB change. The Texans started Watson week 2, on a Thursday night. Of course, he did get into the game week 1. It wouldn't be the worst idea in the world to start him this week. If you think he honestly gives the team the best chance to win and today's win may have salvaged the team's chances at competing this year....you kinda have to play him this week.
  12. They could win the 2nd wildcard and could face them in the NLCS.
  13. We will see where Maddon puts him in the rotation. If he's the 4th starter his potential impact will be limited due to only having 3 starts at most. Eh. 4th in one series doesn't mean 4th in all of them. 4th in NLDS that goes 5, could mean 2nd or 3rd in NLCS....if that goes 6 or 7, he could be in line for Game 1 of the WS and potentially a 2nd or 3rd start if he's performing well.
  14. That's pretty funny. Quintana 13 starts, Montgomery 13 starts, Butler 11, Hendricks missed about 7 starts.
  15. Ha! Quintana had 103 pitches thru 7 and finishes the CG with just 13 more.
  16. Can't decide if I want the Cards or Brewers to win the 2nd wildcard and then make it to the NLCS so the Cubs can beat the horsefeathers out of them. Or if I want them in a 3-way tie the last day of the season only to have both teams forfeit the last game because a Cards player (or coach) DUIs into the Brewers lockeroom killing Ryan Braun.
  17. Went to bed with the Brewers up 3-2 in the 8th and Justin Grimm coming into the game with men on base and only 1 out. There was no way the Cubs were getting out of that inning with no more runs scored.
  18. A lot is based on a few high profile cases that seemingly validate whichever theory you back (good or bad). Not sure any serious study into the topic exists. I do think there are a few main theories that try to at least ascend simply anecdote; 1. Their confidence ruined. "This guy is gonna be so overwhelmed in the moment. You need to put him in a place to succeed or his confidence will be crushed" I personally find this explanation crap. If he can't handle adversity, he isn't a franchise QB 2. You'll get him killed This is basically the David Carr defense and also used anytime it isn't an all pro line established. I generally find this to be bunk too, though there could be an extreme case where it was applicable, I suppose. 3. He needs to learn an NFL offense/reads and/or mechanics. This is similar to 1 in the sense that you're worried the guy will be overwhelmed by the moment, but rather than his mind, you're worried about his skillset. Learning on the fly, a guy may develop bad habits, relying on whatever his particular skill set is, whether than his cannon for an arm or his legs/escapability, etc. rather than developing solid NFL QB skills that will consistently allow him to pick apart NFL defenses. I find this the most convincing argument in general terms. However, whereas it's probably a concern for say, Watson right now who needs to develop a lot of skills, I am not concerned with this line of thinking on Trubisky from what I've seen- his skill set is already pretty advanced, I dont see the big potential for bad habits to form as he learns on the fly. It also probably helps that he doesn't have one overwhelming physical talent he is going to lean on too much. Plus, at the end of the day, the competition at QB is just too lackluster. After all, with most of the success stories on making a QB wait, they sat behind legitimately good talent. Agreed 100% with this. 1 is only an issue if the QB sucks at playing QB. People claim that guys like Aaron Rodgers, Steve Young, Steve McNair, Philip Rivers, etc. are good because they sat as rookies. And guys like Akili Smith, Tim Couch, Christian Ponder, Jamarcus Russell, etc. were bad because their teams were impatient with them and threw them on the field right away. When the common denominator is good QB vs. bad QB. Peyton & Eli Manning, Derek Carr, Roethlisberger all started pretty early on and were fine. Jake Locker, Brady Quinn, Brock Osweiler, etc. sat a year or more and it didn't help any. It's not about sitting vs. not sitting. It's about good QB vs. not good QB. 2 Don't buy that either. The OL isn't that bad. Hell, it's actually pretty decent. If he's getting hit too much, that's on the OC to adjust the game plan/blocking scheme to have extra protection in there. I think the Bears have allowed 4 sacks (not sure how many hits), but Trubisky would have been able to escape at least 2 of those by getting rid of the ball or getting out of the pocket. Doubt he'd be getting hit however much Glennon is either, since he's not a statue. 3 I don't know how you learn those things while not in a game situation. Can't get used to game speed by getting reps at 75% speed in practice. Cutler still had footwork issues when pressured. And like you said, there are plenty of reasons why this shouldn't apply as much to Trubisky as it does to others.
  19. Won't end up mattering, but why not pinch hit Addy for Jay the inning before vs a LHP if u were taking him out any way?
  20. Both are going to play.
  21. What consideration will Devin Hester get for the HOF? Outside of Bears fans Hester is probably more well known. Didn't someone (Vai Sakahama?) already break the return man barrier for HOF consideration? Has to get serious consideration. No primary return man has made it to the Hall. I believe Morten Andersen is the only primary special teamer in the Hall. I'm going to say that he gets a lot of support but does NOT make it in. He's top 10 in all return categories, but the only things he's actually #1 in are punt return TDs and overall non-offensive TDs. I think he'll get more consideration than Brian Mitchell, but if he would have gotten to his punt return yardage record (4,999 for Mitchell, Hester at almost 3700) then he'd be a shoe-in.
  22. Yep. And that includes the Cohen TD which was exactly 10 yards (past the LOS) in the air. The almost TD to Cohen and the Thompson play in the middle of the field are the only ones that were over 15, IIRC.
×
×
  • Create New...