Dunn has not consistently produced for several years. His numbers have been all over the board, actually. I posted this earlier, but the closest thing to consistency Dunn has shown is that his numbers plummet in August and September. You're really reaching here. 2004: .266/.388/.569/.957 2005: .247/.387/.540/.927 2006: .234/.365/.490/.855 2007: .263/.364/.548/.912 That's rock solid compared to targets like Dye, who have been all over the map, or targets like Payton who don't sniff Dunn's down year production. I agree that Dunn has been fairly consistent overall, he has also been a consistently poor second half player. I would like him as a Cub for an entire season(s), but for a stretch run rental Dunn is a poor target, considering the price. Griffey would be much better.