No, it's really not arguable at all. Even in his best year to date, Crede's OPS+ was 19 points lower than ARam's. And that is by far the closest he's been. Ramirez has pretty well destroyed Crede in AVG, OBP, OPS+, SLG, RC/G, EQA, IsoP, BB/K and OPS/RISP every year. And I am leaving out stats like HR/RBI/RC to be fair to Crede, since he hasn't played that much. And even in his best full seasons, Joe wasn't nearly as good. And while Crede is a better defender (and nearly all defensive metrics are severely flawed, and Aramis isn't a bad defender), it doesn't begin to make up for the chasm between the two offensively. Crede has gotten off to a good start, but when you compare the offensive numbers across the board over the past five years, trying to argue that he is as good as ARam is an absolute joke. And ARam is no Pujols, but Crede is closer to Jacobs than ARam, statistically speaking (in fact Mike's career OPS is higher).