You do if your top player is LeBron, Kobe, or Wade. Rose is not the type of player who will be the man on a championship winning team. He is a great player, but not good enough to do that. you have no idea where Rose will go from here. He's shown great signs of continued development the short time he's played in the NBA. I think it's pretty clear he won't be a top 5 player like LBJ, Kobe and Wade. But I'm also pretty confident he will be good enough to be "the man" on a championship winning team. He's not loud, boistrous, or an egomaniacal jerk. He's also shown solid maturity for his age, unlike Lebron. You'll have to excuse me, but I'm not going to count those qualities against him at the ripe old age of 21 until I see what develops in the coming years.