What in the world is your basis for this statement? Basis for which one, Gerut being a 4th OF'er or Gerut defensively? Let's see... Gerut likely won't hit for a high avg., won't hit for much power, has a good eye at the plate, lacks speed, avg. arm. His rookie year was likely the ceiling of his power and has been hampered by knee injuries since. Career EqA of .264, shouldn't hit for much power as he progresses, entering the prime of his career with a bad wheel. Isn't good enough defensively to play CF'er, isn't good enough to hit for a starting corner OF'er. Mix it together and you get a 4th OF'er. Defensively, doesn't have the range of Hairston, better instincts, both have similar arm strength. Hollandsworth, both lack range, Hollandsworth probably has better range, Gerut has a better arm and instincts are similar. Him and Burnitz, Burnitz gets a better jump on the ball and has a more accurate arm.