Sure, but you can't ignore the regression he had the plate last year. Obviously, the position he plays adds a premium to his offensive which pre-'08 were above avg. for a SS and did so even with a poor approach at the plate. It went from bad to awful last year, even with his quick hands and line drive stroke, he's still not good enough to put up similar road numbers expanding his zone the biggest jump was with the off-speed junk from lefties, his strike zone regressed against pitchers, counts, types of pitches, etc. He's not gifted enough with the bat to try and mimic Soriano and his approach for much of '08 wasn't much diff. than when Soriano is struggling.