I think you're underestimating how good Derrick Rose is going to be. Just out of curiosity, would you think this team can compete in the East? Dwayne Wade Ben Gordon Luol Deng Tyrus Thomas Chris Bosh You probably would. And realize that in a few years, Rose might be as good as (or possible better than) Wade. Here are their per-36-minute stats from their rookie years: Wade (age 22): 16.8 points, 4.2 rebounds, 4.7 assists, .465 FG% Rose (age 20): 16.6 points, 3.6 rebounds, 6.2 assists, .474 FG% So, comparing the two player's first years in the NBA, Rose scores at almost the same rate, but more efficiently. He also distributes better. And he's two years younger than Wade. I don't think he'll ever average 28 a game because he'll be playing the point, but I think it's very possible they'll have similar value. I don't think you can *only* compare 2 players based on statistics. Wade is a very good scorer and does it in many ways, from jump shots, to slashing in the lane, plus an amazing ability to draw contact in the lane. Wade seems to have a bigger reach as well, allowing him to get shots up over taller defenders (their height isn't a big difference, Rose is 6-3 and only 20, while Wade is 6-4) I'm not dogging on Rose, I think he is going to be a terrific player and can rival Wades impact. But to just compare them on their rookie numbers isn't telling the whole story. Wade's ability to score is unique and Rose might not be able to score in the same ways. Wades way of scoring might give him a higher ceiling that Rose's abilities might. There's no doubt that Rose is only going to get better though. His jumper is already better than Wade's is right now, and he has the ability to get to the lane easily. His first step is unrivaled in the NBA. I think he'll be a 25ppg scorer when all is said and done, if he doesn't focus more on distribution.