None of the other free agent WR options are currently playing well either. Look it up. Roy Williams - 5 catches for 70 yards, 0 TDs (in 3 games) Sidney Rice was injured the first 2 games and since coming back has caught 11 passes for 188 yards and a TD. Santonio Holmes 13 for 164 and a TD Braylon Edwards has played 1.5 games this year and has 4 for 48 Malcolm Floyd has 9 catches for 158 yards as SD's number 2 WR. Plaxico Burress has 10 catches for 160 yards and 2 TDs as the Jets number 2 WR James Jones has 9 catches for 88 yards and a TD as the Packers number 4 WR Mike Sims-Walker has 11 catches for 139 yards Cant remember if there was anyone else we mentioned back then. No, none of them are dominating, as they all have less receiving yards than Knox (although Rice would if he was healthy for 4 games) but they all have better numbers than Williams (besides Edwards) despite some of them being the team's #2+ WR (Floyd, Burress, Jones) or having an extremely ineffective QB (Rice, Sims-Walker, Edwards). You conveniently fail to mention that Williams missed the end of the first game, all of the second game, probably wasn't 100% against GB, and was victimized yesterday by a run-heavy gameplan. You can also argue that he has suffered from ineffective QB play as well. Besides, my argument wasn't that he has outperformed the other options, but that the other options aren't setting the world on fire either, and they aren't. I mentioned he played in 3 games. I think he played 3 quarters the first game, his most effective game. He missed the 2nd one. You conveniently slide in a comment about him probably not being 100%, but why because he was injured the week before? He played and was ineffective, caught 0 passes, dropped a TD and another pass and was held off the field whenever the Bears were in the red zone in the 2nd half. Sidney Rice was probably less than 100% when he came back from his injury, and yet Tavaris Jackson of all people found him 8 times for 109 yards in that game. And that's fine that none of them are tearing it up. Like I said, 3 of them aren't their team's number 1 receivers, like they would be if they were on the Bears, and 3 of them have mediocre to bad QBs. You could argue that James Jones would have much better numbers if he wasn't his team's 4th option. Or that Mike Sims-Walker would have better numbers if Bradford didn't completely blow this year. And despite this, they all have better numbers than Williams. I can tell this is going to be an agree to disagree argument.