I can kindof see what Kyle is saying. I am normally all for replay. In fact, I want K-zone to call balls and strikes. However, the NFL's "review every scoring play" annoyed me this year. However, as other people mentioned, it was more for stupid rules or the fact that they will still get things wrong after the replay. Sometimes, a TD would be overturned for a rule that no one even really knew about, or a play gets overturned that would have never even been reviewed if it was up to the opposing coach like most plays. For example, it would be sort of annoying when a great run for a touchdown is called back to the 1 inch line because as the player lept to the endzone, his knee may have grazed the grass as he was falling in. Once again, it probably wouldn't have even been reviewed by the opposing coach. I also remember a 40 yard touchdown pass from Rivers to a receiver who had complete control, came down in bounds the entire time and it was overturned because the defender who barely was touching the ball as well was standing out of bounds. Maybe I was just a bitter fantasy owner who had about a TD a week overturned on these types of calls. But I think this is different. I think people will still get the excitement and won't really even think about the overturn until a replay is shown. They aren't stopping the game after every play to think about it. They will still go on as normal, but when someone in the booth sees something wrong--which is when we would all see it on replay as well, they will stop it. I don't think it will ruin any excitement. If anything, instead of just yelling at the screen, fans of the team getting screwed can yell at the screen with the hope of the call being overturned. It isn't like there are some weird rules in baseball. Either the ball was caught or it wasn't. It was either a home run or it wasn't. And if I was a fan of the team that got the benefit of the call, I would have no problem if it was overturned. ETA: Also, how often do plays really need to be reviewed in baseball? Most plays are pretty clear. It isn't like football where plays that could be reviewed happen all the time.