who was it? Haha, he's talking about Jim Thome. I could understand why you're confused since he got essentially everything wrong in his post. Don't let facts get in your way. 2006-2008: Thome-- 111 HR, 295 RBI, .554 Slugging DLee--- 50HR, 202 RBI, .483 Slugging Easy to slurp up the Hendry Kool-Aid for some. If Thome was a free agent during the 2005 offseason, how the hell did the Phillies manage to trade him to the White Sox? And even if you ignore that, this is every bit as important as the offensive stats you posted: Games played at 1B vs. Games played as DH (since Opening Day 2003, which is important, since the Cubs would have been able to sign him as a free agent the previous offseason): Thome: 346 vs. 411 Lee: 922 vs. 5 Thome wouldn't be putting up those offensive numbers if he was playing 1B everyday. The ability to be a DH saved his career. It's even more fun if you take it from Thome's free agency year heading into the '06 season. (Pretty dumb of the Phillies to just release him like that) Thome has played 4 games at 1B from '06 on. This was also the offseason following Derrek Lee beating the ever living [expletive] out of the ball all year. Now if we're talking about not signing Thome to play SS when he became a free again before this year, I wholeheartedly agree.