Do they, though? Between LF/RF/SS/2B/3B there are 3,000 PAs. Add 200 PAs at C for Schwarbs for a total of 3,200 and you break it down this way: Bryant 600, Russell 600, Schwarber 600 (inc. 200 at C/DH), Soler 400, Javy 400, Castro 400, Coghlan 200. I'm still not sold on Coghlan being the real deal. If he is, it becomes a big time crowd. Not to mention LaStella who I guess has some value. However, has Soler been able to stay healthy? What about Baez? Unless there is major clubhouse drama, it might be worth the risk to keep everyone around next year (sorry Jonathan Herrera). This, nicely summarized and put better than what I was trying to say. The only real problem is why keep Coghlan, only to just give him 200 ABs, when you could just give them to Javy and Castro? The answer is: because you can't trust Javy and Castro, of course. But, there is a point where you get diminishing returns from having that many guys that are possibly capable starters. You could trade Coghlan for a bullpen arm, minor leaguers, whatever -- as you could with any of these guys.