I really value that defense in big games, though, and especially when the offense isn't scoring much. The hope is that you put Javy at No. 8, get his great defense at second, and let all the more well-rounded hitters do the damage needed. Zobrist is plenty good defensively at 2B, vs RHP we don’t need two pitchers hitting the lineup. Javy can go get himself a comfortable seat on the bench for them. I trust your defensive rating on Zobrist. In that case, he's a much better option until pitchers accidentally start throwing Javy strikes again.