Yeah he’s largely been the same player every year since then. I get being worried about the injuries but he isn’t really a different player now vs 2016. Maybe he’s lost a little speed. 2015-2016: .285/.378/.524 .385 wOBA, 143 wRC+, .240 ISO, 11% BB, 26% K 2017-2019: .284/.390/.511 .382 wOBA, 147 wRC+, .227 ISO, 12% BB, 21% K You can debate that on the offensive side, but his defense has certainly declined and the metrics bear that out. Yeah that’s the one thing, idk if he’s as bad as he was last year though. He’s probably not -7 DRS bad at 3B, he still rated out pretty neutral in the OF. He probably is in a decline overall defensively and he’s probably never going to rate elite, maybe embracing some more shifting (Ross has hinted he’s gonna shift more, IIRC) could help at least get him back between -2 and +2 or so on the DRS spectrum at 3B and maintain being around 0 in the OF. Also have to wonder how much the knee affected the poor defensive numbers. If he can stay healthy maybe they improve just because of that. Obviously it’s a red flag maybe he’s slowing athletically/health wise and there’s just gonna always be something physically that can hold him back but the knee last year could’ve caused the numbers to be worse than his true talent.