Boss is on vacation, I don't have an appointment until 2:30PM, so why not a far too early what I'd like to see in the offseason.
I'm assuming Bellinger opts in at this point. I'm also assuming that Jed almost has to move some prospects with Caissie/Shaw/Alcantara/Ballesteros/Triantos all likely ready to see time in 2025, unless they fall on their face.
1) I'd like to bring in Carson Kelly(2/20) to split time with Amaya. He'd still get good number of starts behind the plate and other at bats as DH with injuries. He's a good enough back up where you still feel pretty good if Amaya gets hurt or becomes first half Amaya again. He's probably going to take starter money because he probably should be one, but he'd still probably see 250-300 ABs on the Cubs.
2) Bryce Miller/Celesten for Caissie+Triantos. Seattle always needs bats and they acquire 2 that are just about major league ready. Miller has the stuff to be a top 2 starter in this rotation, but he needs some pitch usage tweaks especially on his breaking stuff. Celesten is very highly thought of, but also very far away. He's coming off hamate surgery but he also provides the kind of star power that the current farm is shallow in.
3) Jack Flaherty 4/72- He's been excellent in 2024 and the only thing surpressing the price is his struggles the previous few years prior to this year, but he has a history of being good to elite in 2018 and 2019. It's a Taillon contract, but significantly more upside.
4) Sign David Robertson 2/20- Yeah he's 39 right now but that hasn't stopped him from putting up 3 excellent season in a row, including this one. He'll almost assuredly decline his $7M mutual offer with Texas and he's a guy guy who can play either the setup role or the closer role depending on need.
5) Andrew Nardi for Alfonsin Rosario+Mervis. Nardi is nails on lefties and while the ERA isn't glowing this year, he's also sporting a 63.9LOB%. The FIP, xFIP, xERA all tell a much more positive story, like the one from his 2023 season.
I'm not ready to hand Wicks/Assad a rotation spot and I'd love to move Taillon out, but I don't think that's likely.
C- Amaya(He's shown enough to be a part of the 2025 squad, but there's enough uncertainty that Jed is going to have to spend on a good backup, just in case)
1B- Busch(He's struggling right now, but he's shown enough)
2B- Nico(I'm torn here. I could 100% justifiably see him traded and Shaw plugged in, but would it make the 2025 team better?)
SS- Dansby( better 2nd half with the bat, defense back to elite levels after struggles early)
3B- Paredes(I am worried, but at the same time they're not going to give up on him after such a short time when he has a multi year track record)
LF- Happ(Solid as always)
CF- PCA(Has definitely earned the right to be the guy in 2025)
RF- Bellinger(I'd prefer he opted out because the offensive addition options are really limited if he doesn't, but it's not going to happen. At least this way RF gets a defensive upgrade)
DH- Seiya
Bench- Kelly, Vazquez, Alcantara, TBD on a suitable 3B back up in case Paredes continues to suck
Yeah, they don't really get that elite bat that they need, but at least it's a pretty deep lineup.
SP- Steele/Shota/Flaherty/Miller/Taillon depth Wicks/Wesneski and eventually Horton/Birdsell
This should be a substantial upgrade on the 2024 Cubs with the upside for a dominant rotation.
RP- Robertson, Miller, Hodge, Assad, Brown, Nardi and the last two slots filled in by Neely/Little/Palencia/Pearson depending on health
Not a ton of necessary tweaks, a guy who can get lefties, a guy who can close but has the flexibility to become a setup man if someone like Hodge steps up.