Eh... based on what? 2009 and 2005 are all Lee has on Aramis. I would say they are a wash. I would have been with you and said Aramis but then I actually looked it up. Lee has a higher OPS with the Cubs than Aramis and they both came around the same time (Aramis had half year in 2003, Lee started in 2004). Starting in '04 Aramis has a better OPS by a 3-2 margin with a wash in '07. Aramis has been extremely consistent while Lee has had some ridiculously good years and some mediocre ones but overall Lee has the slightly higher OPS (.923-.909).