Who's going to give up good young pitching for Adam Dunn? THis offseason MLB GMs practically blackballed him because he can't play much defense. To put things in perspective, would you be ok with the Cubs trading Marshall, J. Jackson and someone else (Cashner) for Dunn? Probably not. An offensive starved team like the Giants. Pablo Sandoval's OPS+ is 140. The next highest on that team is Aaron Rowand at 102... Dunn's currently is sitting at 150. He would instantly be the most productive hitter on that team, and a 1-2 of Sandoval and Dunn looks nice. The Giants have the pitching to be able to make it to the postseason, they don't have the offense. Dunn should look like gold to them, and they probably would be able to part with just one top pitcher for Dunn (i.e. Alderson), not several mid-level types. The Giants have Bumgarner in the wings with him. Sure a 1-4 of Lincecum, Cain, Bumgarner, and Alderson looks sick in the future, but a 1-3 without Alderson can do them just fine, and the Nats need good young pitching, and the Giants can afford to part with some (or one). Dunn isn't worth a whole crop of pitchers, but I do believe he's worth one very good one (and maybe a couple of toss-ins), especially when he'll still be under control for another year, albeit at $12 million, but that's still below the average salary of players who are OPS'ing around the same numbers for what he is right now. The Giants need a power bat. The Nats need young pitching. It's a no-brainer.