Disagree. It's a low-risk, low-reward trade that, in the most likely scenario, has us losing extra games in 2012 because we are running out a terrible third baseman who is going to get $1.5 to $2.5 million more than he is worth. Best case scenario Stewart bats .300/.450/.550 with 40 home runs. Worst case scenario he bats .125/.200/.275 and runs over Starlin Castro with his car. Even the most notorious media douches as meh at worst on this trade. I think Kyles the only person out there who has an actual problem with it. Kyle would probably tell you he'd aim for Starlin but miss. Kyle doesn't like Castro either, so he probably wouldn't even care.