Top 5, IMO ... I'm honestly having trouble thinking of a more memorable moment if that had gone in. Jordans shot against Russell, ruths called shot, Buckner ball, fluties hail mary, that's all I got. Duh Laettners shot. Hayward's hypothetical shot >>> Laettner's I would take Hayward's over all of those because it would have won the National Title and because he missed, they lost. While Jordan's won the game and the title, it was Game 6 so even if he missed, the Bulls could still win Game 7. Ruth's called shot was in Game 3 of a sweep. Buckner's was Game 6. Flutie's hail mary was a regular season game. Laettner's was an Elite 8 game. Mazeroski's HR in Game 7 to win the World Series is up there also, though that game was tied when he hit it. Is Mazeroski in the hall of fame if he doesn't hit that homer? I doubt it. That home run gave an individual a lot of accolades compared to individual moments.