I mentioned in my post that I don't always agree with sportswriters (especially about Santo), but I would hope that posters ought to agree that any player elected on the first ballot was a great player (and usually a great hitter). If posters can't agree that players like Carew, Boggs, Brett, etc. were great hitters, then I think their definition of a great hitter is skewed. my goodness, dude, what on earth are you talking about? who the hell said george brett wasn't a great hitter? your posts in this thread have been beyond awful.