If they are in contention in a close race come July, Melvin would likely change his tune. The question is, are they expecting to lose Fielder, Hardy, and Weeks in the next few years and build around Braun, Hart, Gamel, and Escobar, or are they going to try to keep their current window open and try to resign at least to of F/H/W. If they are in that second frame of mind, I could see them going after Peavy.