Sure. Why not? He's a couple years younger than Fontenot and Hoff were last year, with a much better minor league track record. That said, you've got a point. Hoff, I think we can chalk up to sample size, and Soto to injury. Besides, while not all-star quality, Soto hasn't been that far off of adequate production from an average starting catcher. I'm still not sure what's happened to Fontenot, though... His OPS has dropped ~.230 against lefties. So it's not like we can chalk it all up to the fact that he's facing a lot more right handers as the regular starter. Soto had the one big season his final year of AAA, but otherwise both Fontenot and Hoff were better minor league hitters. Soto career minor league: .280/.360/.429/.789 Fontenot career minor league: .291/.366/.437/.803 Hoff career minor league: .288/.344/.485/.829 Soto was called up for good at age 25 though. When Hoffpauir was 25 he was horrible in AAA and his overall numbers didn't start to inflate until he got to repeat AA and AAA multiple times. Fontenot had an entire age 25 and half an age 26 season to pad those overall numbers. It's not very accurate to just say those guys were better minor league hitters.