So you're completely unaware of how many times the "summer swoon" myth has been debunked? Yes, I can see why they hate him, because he has a low batting average (the most cited stat when talking about what a disappointment he is) and he spins when he strikes out (the thing most often referenced when mocking him). Wasn't he also billed as having power and speed? Maybe I'm just making that up, but I don't think so. I didn't think the expectaions where much higher than 15 HRs a year when he signed maybe 20. Not that he has ever reached this, but I don't remember him being expected to be much of a power bat. I think he was billed has having a little more power, but some people assumed he should hit 25. As for speed, I don't remember hearing of him being a burner, but rather a good baserunner and defender.