so you are the 1 vote? I'm number two (easy joke, go ahead if you want). I just look at the playoffs in this conversation, I would rather have a pitcher I know is going to give my team the best chance to win a game than a hitter who (based on the other pitcher) could or could not win the game with his bat. After the last 2 post seasons, I think I like winning that first game, give me Peavy.