I think it might be better to cite those signed that same off-season -- or at least that makes it more fair to both Marquis and Hendry. I think includes Jeff Suppan, Gil Meche, Ted Lilly, Tomo Ohka, and others certainly. But on price, performance, and contract length, Marquis stacks up reasonably well against all those guys (thankfully Lilly has turned it around since Apri). I think when 2009 is added, the average is $9 million/year for Marquis, which is stunning. But Suppan is at $8 million + per year, and Meche is more than $11 million. At the very least, the Cubs $9 million mistake is an average #5 starter in the majors. It's better than having Carl Pavano. Those numbers are actually slightly off. Marquis is only at 7 million per year, and Suppan is at 10.5. Here's the years and average salary for every pitcher who signed multi-year deals that year. Zito. 7 years, 18 million per year Daisuke 6 years, 17.17 million per year (includes posting fee) Meche 5 years, 11 million per year Igawa 5 years, 9.2 million per year (includes posting fee) Suppan 4 years, 10.5 million per year Lilly 4 years, 10 million per year Schmidt 3 years, 15.67 million per year Padilla 3 years, 11.25 million per year Batista 3 years, 8.25 million per year Eaton 3 years, 8.17 million per year Marquis 3 years, 7 million per year Mussina 2 years, 11.5 million a year Mulder 2 years, 6.5 million per year Woody Williams 2 years, 6.25 million per year El Duque 2 years, 6 million per year Ouch. Marquis is probably 2nd or 3rd on production per dollar on that list. That's scary.