Which is basically what I said (well, I left it open with the "almost" part). The coaches should be emboldened to pick Aramis to start because he's better (this year). It will be close. Wright may get it because the game is in NY, even if it's not at Shea. Look at their stats (I'm listing several stats that will be looked at by the people picking, even if they don't matter very much, so be forewarned): Wright: 312 AB's, 48 R, 89 H, 19 2B, 1 3B, 15 HR, 64 RBI, 8 SB, 4 CS, 55 K/48 BB, .285/.378/.497, 11 E Aramis: 291 AB's, 54 R, 84 H, 20 2B, 0 3B, 14 HR, 55 RBI, 1 SB, 1 CS, 53 K/42 BB, .289/.390/.502, 7 E That's about as close as you can get across the board. less than 10 runs and RBI, 1 double off, 1 triple off, 1 home run off, walk and strikeout totals that are very close. Wright's SB's will give him a slight edge, as his CS will mostly be ignored. Aramis's error totals will help him slightly. The only difference in their OBP comes from the fact that Wright has hit 6 sacrifice flies compared to Aramis's 1, and Aramis has been hit 7 times compared to only 2 for Wright. The only difference in their slugging is the slight difference in batting average. With the stats that close, I think it will come down to more of perception than anything else. Wright has the better reputation in the past. Aramis has been in the headlines more because of the Cubs success. Like I said in the beginning, I think the tiebreaker might be the NY factor and Wright will be the starter, but it wouldn't surprise me at all if Aramis got it instead.