Neither is great, but give me the guy that has more upside, plays better defense, hits for more power, and doesnt cost 2.5 million for 2 year. That's fine. I would completely agree with you (although I would have kept DeRosa, not signed Miles, and still traded Cedeno as part of the deal for Heilman). But you said that Cedeno was better specifically at the plate than Miles. And that isn't really true. It's his other things (upside, defense, contract) that makes him the better option, not his hitting.