Mephistopheles

THE GRIT FACTOR OF COURSE seriously its not scientific. i took a range because the values arent precise. it's just a general consensus. hes real bad, we all know that. so that puts him 10-20 below, but hes not braunlike

i dunno, anywhere from -10 to -15.

He's a brick defensively.

Judging by the reaction from this thread, no. http://www.northsidebaseball.com/Forum/images/smiles/icon_biggrin.gif

more or less.

8.69 Jake Peavy 8.46 Albert Pujols 8.28 Magglio Ordonez 8.06 Matt Holliday 7.83 Alex Rodriguez 7.49 David Wright 7.40 Grady Sizemore 7.20 Hanley Ramirez 7.06 Tim Hudson 7.00 Brad Penny 6.88 Chase Utley 6.61 Derrek Lee 6.51 David Ortiz 6.48 Prince Fielder 6.32 Vladimir Guerrero 6.27 C.c. Sabathia 6.12 Jimmy Rollins 5.99 Roy Halladay 5.98 Chipper Jones 5.96 Alfonso Soriano 5.92 Josh Beckett 5.90 Johan Santana 5.84 John Smoltz 5.82 Miguel Cabrera 5.81 Carlos Pena 5.79 Edgar Renteria 5.72 Fausto Carmona 5.70 Aramis Ramirez 5.54 Carlos Beltran

This works better: ("player name" "plays the game the right way")/Games Played*162 89.6 Dustin Pedroia 47.1 Ryan Theriot 40.3 Derek Jeter 32.4 David Eckstein 23.1 Alfonso Soriano 19.8 Manny Ramirez

I dont do GGs.

For the record, Aramis' defense was good.

Yes I watched the games. I can still say that...

well sorta. 20 runs over an average guy. i think soriano had a +16 or 17 uzr this year, missing quite a bit of time on top of that.

How do you figure that Soriano and Lee were more valuable than Ramirez this year? Magic! No seriosuly Derrek Lee had a higher VORP than Aramis this year as well as being a better defender and Soriano was a +20 defender give or take.

who said that? yes hudson and halladay are #2 in their leagues

-25 defense hurts. a lot.

Yes and yes. There are no typos.

How I would vote

you have to get invited to the forum guys

I read it.

C/O of me. National League Cy Young Award: 1. Jake Peavy 2. Tim Hudson 3. Brad Penny 4. John Smoltz 5. Brandon Webb 6. Carlos Zambrano 7. Adam Wainwright 8. Matt Cain 9. Chris Young 10. Roy Oswalt American League Most Valuable Player: 1. Magglio Ordonez 2. Alex Rodriguez 3. Grady Sizemore 4. David Ortiz 5. Vladimir Guerrero 6. C.c. Sabathia 7. Roy Halladay 8. Josh Beckett 9. Johan Santana 10. Carlos Pena American League Cy Young Award: 1. C.c. Sabathia 2. Roy Halladay 3. Josh Beckett 4. Johan Santana 5. Fausto Carmona 6. John Lackey 7. Erik Bedard 8. Dan Haren 9. Kelvim Escobar 10. Joe Blanton National League Rookie of the Year: 1. Troy Tulowitzki 2. Hunter Pence 3. Chad Billinglsey 4. James Loney 5. Ryan Braun National League Most Valuable Player 1. Jake Peavy 2. Albert Pujols 3. Matt Holliday 4. David Wright 5. Hanley Ramirez 6. Tim Hudson 7. Brad Penny 8. Chase Utley 9. Derrek Lee 10. Prince Fielder Most Valuable 50 Players 1. Jake Peavy 2. Albert Pujols 3. Magglio Ordonez 4. Matt Holliday 5. Alex Rodriguez 6. David Wright 7. Grady Sizemore 8. Hanley Ramirez 9. Tim Hudson 10. Brad Penny 11. Chase Utley 12. Derrek Lee 13. David Ortiz 14. Prince Fielder 15. Vladimir Guerrero 16. C.c. Sabathia 17. Jimmy Rollins 18. Roy Halladay 19. Chipper Jones 20. Alfonso Soriano 21. Josh Beckett 22. Johan Santana 23. John Smoltz 24. Miguel Cabrera 25. Carlos Pena 26. Edgar Renteria 27. Fausto Carmona 28. Aramis Ramirez 29. Carlos Beltran 30. Orlando Hudson 31. Curtis Granderson 32. Brandon Webb 33. Placido Polanco 34. Todd Helton 35. Torii Hunter 36. Aaron Rowand 37. Troy Tulowitzki 38. Jose Reyes 39. John Lackey 40. Ichiro Suzuki 41. Erik Bedard 42. Carlos Zambrano 43. Dan Haren 44. Brian Roberts 45. Russell Martin 46. Adam Wainwright 47. Matt Cain 48. Alex Rios 49. Mike Lowell 50. Jorge Posada

The Vols are inferior to UK, SC and UF. You're assuming that they're equal. They aren't.

Based on what? And as long as teams keep trying to shut down Rice and making Rutgers QB beat them, opposing teams are going to have success against Rutgers. Based on Michigan playing like a top ten team the last five weeks.

Tim answers my PMs relatively quickly. Usually the next time he's on.

Tennessee is going to have to run the table in order to win the East. SC or UK will knock them off, I think. It looks as if one of these teams could beat the other two, then they are in {UK, SC, UF}. UK's out. If UF beats UK, the east will probably come down to Spurrier vs the Gators.

Longer than it probably would have been if Tim and 1908 checked their emails. It was only a few days after they did that before I was unbanned. It only took them three weeks to check them!

I was banned because people moaned and groaned about me.