it's been pointed out by others, but Soriano's drop in production could be attributed to other things besides his place in the order. at some point during his tenure at Texas, the league started to figure him out. his production dropped overall, not just when hitting out of the leadoff spot. eventually, Soriano made adjustments to the way pitchers were attacking him and improved on those numbers. i am not totally dismissing the whole "he's comfortable at leadoff" arguement, but there may be more to it than that. i would prefer to see him hitting lower in the order, but i'm not sure what the alternative is. i'm still skeptical that Theriot will maintain his current obp, i guess. if they did make a change, a 1/2 of Theriot/Murton would probably make the most sense. I'm not saying he is more comfortable but there as to be some reason he is better up there. Maybe he sees better pitches because there is no one on base. Maybe his numbers in the first inning are incredibly higher than his career norms. I don't know how to find that information but I think it would be interesting to look up. I could honestly see Soriano's numbers being much higher in the first inning than they are compared to any other. Here are his 3-year splits: To leadoff an inning - .299/.341/.563 Nobody on - .278/.325/.530 Runners on - .269/.335/.503 He actually had a lower OBP when there's nobody on base from 2004-2006, but slightly higher to leadoff an inning. Of course, batting leadoff, you're probably more likely to bat with nobody on more often than you actually leadoff an inning. But the numbers are pretty close, likely in the range of normal fluctuation.