You don't get points one-at-a-time when you win shootouts. You get 2. They've gotten 6 points from OT wins, another 8 from SO wins, and 7 points from OTLs. They've outscored their opponents by just 17 goals. I don't really get that they've been wildly inconsistent as much as they just haven't been very good. They had a nice stretch in the middle of November, but that's about it as far as impressive success. Their longest win streak is 5, and that started with 3 OT/SO wins and was against some pretty weak competition. They've lost 3 games in a row on 3 different occasions already. They aren't a bad team by any stretch, but they just aren't impressive. It's disappointing to me that after all the turnover they haven't been able to take a step forward yet. To date they appear to be a pretty clear tier below the elite teams in the league like Boston, Detroit and even the Rangers. And it's not like they've dealt with the issues that a team like Pittsburgh has had to deal with, missing MVP caliber players for extended periods of time. goal differential is slightly misleading, since they're tied for second-worst in goals against in the west yet lead the west in goals scored. they do two things consistently: score a lot and get scored on a lot. yet, they don't necessarily always do both of those things at the same time, edmonton for example. what i'm ultimately most baffled by is the expectation that one of the younger teams in the nhl, which as you clearly point out, has undergone pretty significant roster turnover, should be elite. maybe you should think about adjusting your expectations. this team has very clearly taken a step forward in regards to the young talent brought in through trades and the draft. however, getting rid of campbell and choosing jammer over niemi are probably the ultimate moves that have put this team in the position it is in. that's not a problem with taking a step forward, that's a problem with undermining forward progress by miscalculating roster moves. this team doesn't play defense well. however, the fact that they can light the lamp with the best of them should give a little more optimism that if, and only if, quality defensive talent is brought in, this team will take the next step.