why not? They are both sports that in particular cases ask a person to perform in a high pressure situation. Where is the grey area? If you can't compare the situation to other sports, then what can you compare it to? And if its incomparable, it's impossible to make an argument for either side. Because of the skill sets involved. One involves repeating a simple, repetitive motion the exact same way. The other involves an amazing feat of reflexes and hand-eye coordination and virtually no conscious thought. More comparable to a free-throw would be a pitcher in a 3-0 count with the bases loaded in a tie game in a walk-off situation. And yes, you can still make arguments for both sides. They just have to be objectively based, not founded in "it seems like it is this way" common-sense arguments. First off, I'm not saying that clutch hitting is a real stat or even that that BA with RISP is even important. I'm just simply showing that their is a real human side to the game that should be accounted for in the mix of all these stats. That said, you proved my point exactly. A hitter sees a pitch exactly the same each at bat, depending on what the situation is in the game or even if there are runners to be driven in. It is what the stakes are and the importance of the AB that determines how much pressure is put on the hitter(or how much he places on himself). Surely you cannot object that some people are better in clutch situations than others in any aspect of life. It's simply human nature that some people buckle down and concentrate more when the most is on the line (Jordan for example). Secondly, as hard as it is to accomplish, especially to us regular guys, hitting a baseball is a repetitive motion for MLB players. They have seen thousands of pitches ranging in speeds and motions. Sure, the success rate for free throws is much higher than getting a hit, but that isn't the question at hand. The question is how do people perform when the situation is of the most importance? The answer is that it varies from individual to individual. Thirdly, your situation involving a pitcher throwing 3-0 pitch is unreasonable. The fact that he fell to 3-0 in the first place is probably due to pressure at hand. Could it just be the luck of the draw that he fell to 3-0? Sure. In my mind it has more to do with the situation at hand. After all that, the most common theme in the scenario is that sometimes people come through in clutch situations and sometimes they don't. Although, there are SOME situations in which people excel (or fail) in situations such as those more times than not.