What catchers are those? McCann and Miller are the only ones with a higher OPS, and they don't have enough ABs to qualify(only 4 catchers have, Barrett leads them by about 90 points in OPS). There's no way that Barrett isn't in right now, and it's more likely that McCann and especially Miller level off than Barrett. McCann and Miller have a better OPS. Estrada has 33 RBI. Piazza is close numbers wise and has the name, which is very huge. If Ross or Bard get more ABs and come anywhere close to maintainnig their numbers, they are locks, but they are wildcards for now. I certainly don't see Bard getting the ABs with Piazza there, but with the DH, who knows.