Todd Walker is not the best defensive 2nd Baseman, but I think he gets a really unfair rap. Take this comparison from his last full year, 2002. The next year, Luis Castillo won the Gold Glove at 2B in the NL. Castillo is considered one of the best defensive 2nd Basemen in the game. Numbers don't tell the whole story, but they do tell some of it. L. C. 2003: 152 games, 286 putouts, 433 assists, 10 E, 99 DP, .986 F% T. W. 2002: 154 games, 315 putouts, 438 assists, 8 E, 93 DP, .989 F% The knock on Walker is his range and inability to turn the DP, but as those statistics show, Walker obviously got to as many balls (or more) and turned double plays at the same frequency as Castillo. The next year for Walker was not quite so good defensively. He played in less games (139) and commit double the errors (16). Red Sox management claimed that no team had more hits that got through the right side than they did (an obvious knock on Walker), but I think it is kinda obvious that it is a concentration/work issue more than it is a "inability to field" issue. To me, the 02 stats on Walker show that he can clearly play defensively. The question is why not every year?