I still don't understand why you feel that way. If they ink Schmidt and manage to deal for a corner OFer of value, will your opinion change? No. MLB is currently giving birth to a flock of albatrosses. This pattern of giving so-so players superstar contracts based on one great year is going to come to an ugly end. There's no way this level of stupidity can remain unacknowledged for long. As long as the Cubs don't give so-so players superstar contracts, it's not an issue for them. With $115m available this year, blowing up and starting fresh was a bad idea. So you think Soriano will justify his salary in RF for 8 years? I don't. No I don't. But that doesn't justify not getting involved in the market. Every WS winner has players who don't justify their contracts. Jeter hasn't come close to justifying his contract, but the Yankees aren't suffering. If you refuse to sign any player that might not live up to his contract, you will not have a team. That's not how a big market team plays ball. The Mets wouldn't have contended for the NLCS if they didn't had out contracts that won't be "lived up to". Blowing it up and starting over was an option back in the late 90's and early 00's, when the Cubs farm was stacked and the major league roster was barren. That was not an option this year, not with a barren farm and major league roster with as much talent as its ever had. Starting over would just delay the Cubs chances of ever actually winning for at least an additional 5 years over what they already are.