I want max production for the $$. Padilla and Lilly are going to cost you $20MM/year. Schmidt will cost $15MM, maybe $16MM tops. With that $4MM to $5MM, you can snag a Jon Lieber (Philly will cover part of his $$ to move him), or move some talent for a Westbrook or Jennings, which would likely involve a net increment of salary around the $5MM mark. Schmidt + anyone like that > Padilla + Lilly, for equal $$. We need a #2 starter, not four #4's. Did you miss what I wrote? I'm all for Schmidt. I'd love to get him. The problem is he's only one man, there's no guarantee you get him. If they don't, I'm fine with Padilla and Lilly. The Cubs don't need four #4's, but they do need 5 starting pitchers, and currently only have 2 who are good bets to pitch well for a full season.