I have a problem with both. I hate the idea of tenure in baseball. If you've had a job before, you're automatically assumed to be qualified for that job now. No, I think you do kind of agree with the idea, but maybe not to the extreme that Dusty and others do. Do you really think that Pierre has to out-preform Greenberg in SP to get the starting spot? Does Lee need to look over his shoulder and worry about Dope? Should Prior be concerned that if Hill out pitches him this Spring, that his job is at stake? Easy answer: no. Hard answer: what if they go 0-50 during the cactus league? Maybe? It's all relative. Pierre vs Greenberg and Lee vs Dope is not close to the same thing. Grissom is coming off a terrible year, he was never that good to begin with, he's really old and quite possibly done. He should have to prove he deserves a job. Lee proved he deserved his job, as did Pierre.