I'm saying stereotypical leadoff hitters are ridiculously overrated by some in baseball, including Hendry and Dusty. I'm not talking about your prototypical leadoff hitter, the guy who will get on base 40% of the time, take lots of pitches, walk, steal at an efficient clip, etc. I'm talking about stereotypical leadoff hitters, as in Dusty's insistence that the short fast black centerfielder must be the leadoff hitter, or that the leadoff hitter must be a short fast guy. Juan Pierre is a stereotypical leadoff hitter. The Cubs willingness to trade a lot for him was both obvious from the start and absurdly ridiculous. It would be similar to paying big bucks for an innings eating starting pitcher who doesn't pitch effectively at all, and is, in fact, below average in terms of ERA+ in comparison to the rest of the league. When the Cubs decided they needed a leadoff hitter, aside from putting themselves behind the negotiating 8-ball by letting the world know what they were hot and heavy for, they foolishly decided that the most important aspect of the leadoff hitter's game was his speed, and that everything else was secondary. Any short fast dark skinned athlete can be a stereotypical leadoff hitter. But there aren't many prototypical ones. If you got one, great, but don't go bidding heavily on stereotypical leadoff men thinking they will be as good as a prototypical leadoff hitter.