Not likely. If either threw 180 innings with an ERA+ around 105-115, they'd help this staff. I think Padilla is most likely to accomplish that. Sure, more likely than Meche, but check out his past 3 seasons. I'd pass. I've checked out his entire career. I believe the increased workload from reliever to 200 IP starter was very taxing on him, and he suffered in 2004 and 2005. Plus, I believe his 2006 proved he could get back to the 200 IP level. And his 2nd half 2005 combined with 2006 showed he could once again be effective while racking up innings. He's got a career ERA+ of 106, he suffered a setback in 2004 that carried into 2005, but was very good before 2004, and pretty good starting in the 2nd half of 2005 going forward. I think he's very likely to be a good pitcher the next couple years. No, he won't remind us of Prior, Wood, Zambrano from 2003, but you won't find anything like that in this market. The Cubs need multiple starters. Ideally they get a top of the rotation guy, but there are very few of them. And Padilla is very close to the top of my second tier of pitchers.