That kind of explains the "last calendar year" bit. When he's healthy he hits. He's 36 and was slumping pretty hard for a month plus prior to the injury last year. Again, he's not a .700 OPS guy yet, but incredulity at the idea that he isn't considered an offensive machine isn't really well founded. He's been declining and will continue to no doubt. However, your argument is that he's 36 and slumped for a month a year ago. I think it would be silly not expect a .800+ for the remainder of the year and next season to boot, granted he's healthy. When he's healthy he hits.