Here are the second half numbers for those three. Tell me who is who... BA, OBP, SLG, OPS 287, 357, 572, 939 319, 390, 522, 912 311, 358, 512, 870 Both Lee and Soriano will be 31 for the majority of the season and are probably reaching the end of their primes while Murton will be 25 all of next season and hasn't even reached his prime yet. I don't know how you can say it is a risk not worth taking that a 25 year old, like Murton, will be better than two 31 year olds. I also don't think Murton will be a monster like these guys in the homerun and RBI department but he brings other things to the table. I see Murton turning into a player that is much more similar to JD Drew than either Lee or Soriano. Lastly, if the Matt Murton we saw in the second half will be there for the next ten years I'll be very pleased. Heck, even if his OPS levels out at 850-875 I'll be very happy. But you have to believe that he will develop a little more power as he gets older.