Dammit, I just got home...what the hell happened to Hill? He gave up 4 HR's?!? This is his 3rd mediocre/crappy start in a row...the pessimist in me says he's hurt.
So far your argument boils down to this one instance where unfortunately he didn't make it to base. By that logic, that is cancelled out by his single the previous day where he tied or won (I can't remember which) the game.
Injured or not, I'm sick of him acting like he NEEDS to get a strikeout when a big situation comes up instead of just attempting to get the out any way he can.