Yeah Theriot is another Neifi except he plays all out and doesn't make stupid boneheaded mistakes. And Theriot scored 80 runs last year. If he batted leadoff all year he would score 110. Thats not worthless. Theriot isn't great by any stretch of the imagination but he has okay. You can't have a Sori or anything close to it at every position. !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! What would you put an "OK" player in the slot that sees the most AB's? "Plays all out" means zilch. And please explain how Theriot is "mistake-free" and Neifi was making them left and right in such stark contrast? THEY'RE BOTH AWFUL BASEBALL PLAYERS WHO SHOULD NOT START.
Just stop it. Stop. I'm sick of this garbage defense of a garbage player who belongs on the garbage pile with garbage like Neifi Perez. Theriot has proven nothing except he's barely a baseball player. Soriano has actually proven he's infinitely more valuable in the leadoff role because he scores runs. That's what you want your top of the order hitters to do. Theriot is worthless. WORTHLESS. It's been posted over and over and over again wih excellent and well reasoned arguments as to how bad Theriot is...at this point, some people are just refusing to see it. He's yet another Neifi.
And our leadoff hitter. Look, straight up, anyone who thinks he should hit at the top of the order, for ANY reason, is baseball-y [expletive]. Stop arguing for it, he sucks, end of story.
Speed is almost totally irrelevant. You want guys who can get on base and/or score. DeRosa, Fukudome, Soriano and Murton (if he was up) all make infinitely better options in the 1-2 slots. There's zero reason for a hitter as inadequate as Theriot to ever hit anything besides 7-8.
Why? Seeing better pitches doesn't help enough with someone who is a mediocre or worse hitter. That's like saying Juan Pierre would hit more if he saw better pitches. Hell, Theriot is just like Pierre as a "threat" at the plate...pitchers will feed him anything because he's barely gonna take any pitches or he's likely to just weakly ground/fly out.
Pie's been hitting well...so has Cedeno, Fontenot and Theriot. Not that spring success means they'll be able to pull anything off, bt it would be nice if they ended up not being complete black holes with the bat.
:roll: What the hell. They do know we have Theriot playing short, right? So, wait, why isn't DeRosa considered a gritty B.A. like theriot is? I mean he's white, he even has the 5 o clock shaddow beard half the time... Derosa is a decent hitter. Gritty players are generally poor hitters or have a last name of Jeter. He's also too tall and looks too old. Gritty players tend to be stuck looking like they're barely out of puberty and are often bordering on midgetdom.